Archive for the ‘Advertising in tough times’ Category

Category Dominance

Friday, August 27th, 2010

Micky and MeYou cannot “un-ring” a bell. Years ago I read a book the changed my life in terms of advertising. Once I consumed the concepts of “Positioning: the battle for your mind.” by Al Ries and Jack Trout, I was never able to look at the marketing world without seeing behind the scenes of advertising and marketing.

The concept of positioning is simple. It says that human beings can only track a limited number of items in a product or service category, i.e. five brands of soft drinks, seven brands of bread, or four brands of gasoline. Each brand through its advertising and marketing efforts establish themselves on the rungs of a mental ladder. The best rung is the top one, category dominant. We all know Coca Cola, Amazon.com and Microsoft. They are much more recognizable than Verner’s, Lord and Taylor and Oracle.

Far too few retailers understand the power of positioning. They simply rely on people “knowing them.” Or sometimes worse, they accept their placement on the hierarchy of brands without attempting to influence it in any way.

Category dominance means you are the first brand to come to mind when the category is mentioned. If you cannot be dominant in the category, create a new category. 7-Up did so by creating the “Uncola” category. Avis made a category about service rather than size in the car rental industry with “We try harder.” Category dominance can be achieved by selling your unique sales proposition, that one thing where you are stronger than everyone else.

The two most memorable positions are first and last. Being in the middle is purgatory. You are not good enough to brag about, nor are you bad enough to pity. Your best option is to create a new game and category based upon your relative strength. Remember that it is easier to win the game when you create the rules.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Keys to making ads work

Friday, June 11th, 2010

P0000311There are three basics to making your advertising work. They are: consistency; frequency; and anchoring. If you remember your psychology 101 you know about Pavlov and his dogs. Pavlov put dogs into a cage and rang a bell. When he rang the bell, he gave the dogs a piece of meat. After consistently doing ringing the bell over a period of time with a great amount of frequency, whenever Pavlov rang the bell, the dog immediately began to salivate, even before seeing the meat to which the action was anchored. Pavlov anchored this experiment with something the dogs enjoyed and even wanted; the meat.

Many advertisers understand consistency and frequency. Sending the same message over and over with frequency instills the singular message you want your target to receive. But often anchoring is mishandled. Far, far too often advertisers believe “saving money” (low prices) is the correct anchor. It is almost universally not the correct anchor! Remember “not buying your product,” is so much more inexpensive than any low price you can offer. Never pose that price is any form of barrier to owning your product or you are countering your own sales potential.

If he was inconsistent in his approach, Pavlov would have just frustrated the dog and confused it as to what the bell meant. Lacking frequency by only offering the bell every once in a great while would have allowed the dog the luxury of forgetting the meaning and made the learning cycle incredibly long and nearly impossible.

But giving adequate frequency, a single message (consistency) and a perfect anchor, something for which the dog already had a strong desire, Pavlov created a perfect advertising message, made strong enough in a short time to elicit a physical response to just the sound of a bell.

Earlier I mentioned that advertisers understand consistency and frequency. Yet far too many advertisers have the courage to correctly practice those in their advertising. Instead they feel compelled to go for short-term results (as in very little frequency), or far worse they change tactics over and over trying to find the right formula and in doing so establish no consistency at all. Knowing how to do something does not insure we will do it. After all we know that the only way to lose weight is to burn more calories than we take in each day, yet as a nation over 70% of us (including me) are overweight.

Good advertising practices take some discipline to get started and to maintain. It is not really hard, we just need to determine a strategy and stick with it. But the strategy must employ the three basics.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Ready-Fire-Aim

Wednesday, December 30th, 2009

John Boggs“Life isn’t about waiting for the storm to pass. It’s about learning to dance in the rain.”

Everyday I talk to business people who beg off in making a decision by saying, “I am not ready yet.” They’re right and they are wrong. Are they comfortable moving forward with all of the answers to the questions that will arise? No. But what else do they need in order to move forward? Nothing.

Not long after Sadam Hussein invaded Kuwait, the US Military was mobilized to the area and the world at large was for the first time, treated to real-time video broadcasts of war. One of the things we witnessed each night on television with the attack on Iraqi forces was streams of tracer bullets in the night as seen through night vision lens on the camera. They appeared as green dots on the screen being shot toward the target. The tracers are used so that the gunners do not go through the traditional “ready-aim-fire” to hit their target. With tracers the gunners go, “ready-fire-aim-fire-aim-fire-aim….,” the tracers providing a visual stream of bullets going to the target that could be aimed in real time.

Professional marketers employ the same thing tactics. They begin the process of marketing their product and continually adjust their marketing message as they monitor feedback in terms of the results coming in. The faster the feedback the closer to real-time they get. Many marketers employ multiple channels simultaneously.

A few years ago, I did some business the Home Shopping Network in St Petersburg, FL to sell product on television for the publishing company I was working for. I was given a tour of the television studios where the shows are shot live. Most stood quiet with the props and products laying on tables but nobody around. When we were shown into the studio that was doing the live broadcast we were asked to be quiet and not interrupt the hostess nor the producer. What was remarkable was that the hostess who was looking into the camera and talking about the virtues of the product had an earpiece in her ear listening to the producer give her instructions while she was selling on air. The producer was watching a computer screen linked to the call center that was receiving literally hundreds of calls per minute purchasing the product being touted.

I was shown the chart of the calls and sales as it rose and fell according to what the host said. The producer acted like a conductor directing symphony. As the hostess hit a topic that spiked sales the producer spoke into her earphone and told her to keep going with that topic. As sales slowed he told her to move on. When sales dropped below 200 per minute he told her to move to the next product. It was amazing to watch these two dance with real-time results and in a matter of seconds, maximize the time they spent on the air in terms of dollars and cents – actually tens of thousands of dollars and cents per minute. This is the ultimate of “ready-fire-aim-fire-aim….,”

“Getting ready” is not generating sales. At best it is activity that is a precursor to selling, at worst it is an excuse for indecision, but never is “getting ready” the same as “doing business.” I believe that “management is the act of making adjustments to the current state of activity.” Yet if there is no activity, there can be no adjustment. The most important thing in business is to get moving. Making adjustments is what business people do, not getting ready. You cannot improve your business by waiting, doing nothing, or getting ready. Get things started, then like the Home Shopping Network hostess and producer, read your feedback and adjust until you accelerate your business to the level you desire. Then find ways to sustain it. Just don’t wait until you are ready.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

How to get more from your traditional advertising budget

Tuesday, September 29th, 2009

One of the best sources you can have for market research and current trends is your advertising sales representative. I know, many times advertising people are pushy. Some are not too subtle and others seem to be single-minded in their pursuit of closing sales. They always seem to be selling something.

But consider this: the average advertising salesperson speaks with thirty to fifty businesses per week. They consistently have conversations about where local and regional business has been, is currently and where it may be going. They know your business, your competitor’s business and the business of those who are successful as well as those who are struggling. They spent more time in a week analyzing best advertising practices than most businesses do in an entire year!

Some salespeople get by on their personality. For these few, their charming demeanor wins more sales than their knowledge. However, the majority of salespeople are hard working, knowledgeable, and in touch with current market research. In order to answer the vast arrange of advertisers’ questions, they spend a large amount of time learning the current market’s economy, best advertising practices, and what the winners are doing that keeps them winning.

I generally expect those who sell to me to keep me informed of what is happening in the industry. My expectations are to be told about new trends, to be called when something happens that affects my business, and to be given the benefit of my salesperson’s experience with companies similar to mine. In essence, I expect my salesperson to be on my staff but not on my payroll. I feel I deserve this service because I buy long term, advertise consistently and I am pretty much a trouble-free advertiser. Therefore, I expect to get added value from someone looking out for my business in ways that do not cost me anything.

Many advertisers fail to take full advantage of the information salespeople have to offer. And too often, salespeople fail to share vital market information that does not immediately lead to a sale. The typical salesperson/advertiser dynamic is one of selling and avoiding being sold. Because of this preoccupation by both sides, mental space for a meaningful exchange of market information usually does not exist.

My advice is to require each of your advertising representatives to keep you informed about the market. As a matter of fact, all things being equal, I would recommend that you advertise only with those companies who routinely supply you with such a service.

You must understand that ethics also apply to the information you should receive. My sales staff is aware that they are subject to immediate termination for revealing any confidential marketing information about any of their advertisers. The issue of ethics among salespeople is something that we all have a vested interest in. Advertisers need to restrain themselves from tempting salespeople to cross the line. Media managers must be very specific about acceptable and unacceptable behavior from salespeople in this area. And finally, salespeople need to practice restraint when they are the beneficiary of confidential information.

To share someone’s advertising or marketing plan before it becomes public knowledge is the most serious violation of salespeople/client confidentiality. A good test is to ask yourself: “if this were my company’s information, would I want to see it shared, possibly with a competitor?” If the answer is no, be very careful sharing anything with that salesperson.

When you find a good account manager you should find a way to work with them. A good salesperson from a medium or small circulation publication will do more for your business than a so-so salesperson from the largest circulation publication. As I have said throughout ADvice, a well written and targeted ad seen by a few will get more results than a poorly written ad seen by thousands. This truth extends to the service extended by a salesperson. Good marketing information used in a medium circulation publication will do more than poor information or no information used in a large circulation publication.

Good advertising salespeople are trained to help you grow your business. They can be a great resource if you use them. Many can tell you how much your business will grow through advertising, how long it will take, and how to track your growth so you know where the increases came from. Others can help you target your advertising message by surveying their audiences to determine preferences toward your products. Some can survey new products and advertising approaches as a form of test marketing. Very few can or will offer these services to “prospects.” Almost all offer some type of value-added services to “customers.”

As you negotiate your annual advertising buys, determine the various services available to your from your salesperson. As you leverage your annual budget, secure these services. Ask for more value when the media offers no further discounts. Find and use good market research.

Great media salespeople coach their clients in certain areas. Have ever noticed that in every field of human endeavor where performance counts, great coaching is integral to excellent performance, except in business. Too many of us refuse to accept advice or coaching from outsiders. The best coaches are no better than the ones they coach. But they do offer an objective perspective that is critical to success. Salespeople see the good, the bad, and the ugly nearly every day in your industry. Allow them to share or even coach you with the unique perspective that they can bring to you and your business. After all, you don’t have to use their advice. But you might want to.

Finally, ask yourself a question I often ask when talking to advertisers. If you do not make and address daily plans for the growth of your business, who is going to do it for you? Few others in the world are committed to your success. There are few others outside of your family who have a vested interest in this area. Your salesperson does have a vested interest, with the understanding that as your business grows, so will his.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Sale – Market share 50% off

Friday, September 25th, 2009

In their newly released book, The Three Laws of Performance: Rewriting the Future of Your Organization and Your Life, published by Jossey-Bass, the authors Steve Zaffron and Dave Logan assert that people react perfectly to their interpretation of events. People’s actions are congruent with how the world occurs to them. Helping them to interpret what occurs for them in a new and empowering way is the key to changing, and more importantly, improving performance.

Sometimes the obvious and most direct solution is the hardest one to accept. If that were not true, there would be virtually no response to the get-rich-quick schemes and scams that abound all around us, especially in times like now of economic stress and of great change.

Most everyone knows that Warren Buffet is an American investor, businessman and philanthropist. He is one of the world’s most successful investors, and the largest shareholder and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway. One of his guidelines for investors is to “buy fear and sell greed.” What he means is to buy when the vast majority is fearful of the future and thus selling their investments. This is the best time to buy at bargain prices. He also suggests selling investments when confidence is high and everyone’s demand of buying is driving the prices to higher points.

I cannot imagine many who would not want the financial success that Mr. Buffet has worked so hard to enjoy. In times of less economic extremes, being able to judge the “fear,” and the “greed,” mentioned by Mr. Buffet is more of an art because it is not as obvious as now. But now, the fear is so prevalent that in spite of what is in front of us, most are running with the herd. Even those in a position to take advantage of bargains in the stock market are selling.

Seeing the stock market as an opportunity right now indeed takes a new and empowering interpretation of current events. Just as it does for businesses in our crafting industry to see that we are in the midst of a market-share sale. A great portion of the companies in our industry are pulling back their investments into their own success and market share, choosing instead to reserve cash. We all know that during times of economic crisis that our industry seems to do OK because people have more of a tendency to cocoon and do entertaining and less-expensive things at home. Crafting easily fills that need.

Yet the fear in other markets is causing companies in ours to step back and react as if things are really bad. From the reports we have seen, things are not all that bad. My company in many areas is doing very well this year. And, in fact, many of those we deal with are doing much better than most would suspect.

So why is everyone acting as if it is worse than it is? Maybe we don’t want to be irresponsible and get caught by surprise by some impending economic doom. As Zaffron and Logan would say, we are acting congruent with how things are occurring to us. We are reacting perfectly to the interpretation of events that says the economy has slowed. But what if our interpretation of the economy in general is incorrect in our specific and targeted market? Opportunities may not be seen as such. We may not only view the glass as half empty, we may also believe that nobody wants the water.

People tend to make more decisions based upon emotions than they make based upon logic. During times of stress many of us become like an exposed nerve irritated at the very presence of anything that threatens our view of the future. But even Warren Buffet’s logic of buying fear and selling greed is not enough for us to take advantage what might lie before us.

In the meantime, companies that have built market share are cutting back on their marketing efforts and are not adequately defending what they spent so much to attain. Market share in many categories is available for the investment of pennies compared to the dollars you might have to invest in a stronger economic time to actually compete.

There are stories of many companies that exist today who stole market share in previous economic slowdowns. Their critics call them lucky. But those who fought the battle will tell you that they bought their market share when it was on sale. It was on sale when their competitors thought cash was more important than prosperity.

Zaffron and Logan would say to look at yourself and your company a year or so down the road in a dominant position in your market, enjoying the benefits of everyone knowing you and being the first option that comes to mind. If in fact that is where you will be then, what steps must you take now to get there? Wouldn’t you rather buy that market share now for 50 cents on the dollar rather than when things are strong and you may have to spend a dollar and 25 cents against the dollar for that type of growth?

Our economy will improve. Of that we are certain. How long it will take, we do not know. But if history has taught us much, it should have taught us that the difference between winning and losing may be only one or two decisions. Those decisions may rest solely on our interpretation of the glass being half empty or the glass being half full. Can we afford not to invest in our future when many seem to be running away from it?

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Improving sales when times are tough

Monday, June 29th, 2009

There are times when sales come easily, and times when they do not. Whatever the reasons, the results need to be the same. You will always have bills to pay. Obligations for the most part do not vary when there is a downturn in the economy or in your particular business segment. As I tell my salespeople, you cannot let the variables determine your results; therefore, it must be your effort that becomes the variable. You must work a little bit harder to win dollars that not long ago seemed to flow in without much effort.

Tom Peters, of In Search of Excellence fame, writes in his 1987 book Thriving on Chaos in the chapter titled Launch a Customer Revolution, “No department, including legal and accounting, should exist to protect the firm.” In a customer revolution, every department is customer-oriented. And with specific insight he re-defines profit by looking at it from inside total customer satisfaction: “Long-term profit equals revenue from continuously happy customer relationships minus cost.” Continuously happy customer relationships are a performance goal that leads to profit; this outlook changes some of the typical business moves made when things get tight.

Also from Thriving on Chaos are these words from Domino Pizza’s Phil Bressler, addressing other franchisees: “Sales building is the way to profitability. You can only cut your costs so low before they hurt the customer. You can never raise your sales too high.” Advice for building sales profitability comes from delivering more value to more customers rather than the traditional business model of cutting costs to deliver the product less expensively, or to deliver less product in order to enhance margins.

Prepare for Growth

When you think about it, adding product value while others are cutting services and quality is not only a solid business move, it virtually ensures an increase in market share when the market regains its health. Peters suggests doubling the sales force during down periods to increase sales pressure and customer service above and beyond the competition.

Another thought to consider is this. When times are good and sales are brisk, there occurs an atmosphere of being too busy to build and develop new markets. The arrogance of easy sales leads companies to be less customer-focused because sales are not won through hard-fought battles.

Typically, companies design themselves to achieve economies with employees giving 100 percent effort. When this occurs, where is the room for growth? Where are the energy and resource reserves that could be used to take the production and revenues to the next level? Certainly it will not be done by new employees that need to be trained to participate in a productivity explosion.

Most often companies do just the opposite. They cut capacity by cutting labor. Lowell Mayone vice president of Hallmark in 1987 says, “If we have too many people, we consider it a management problem, not an employee problem.” In truth, management is responsible for developing plans and products to utilize av ailable labor. A failure to allocate labor resources and generate a profit is indeed failure of management.

When the going gets tough, the tough get going. Well maybe. I would say that when the going gets tough, you severely test your customer relationships. More often than not, consumers and businesses alike cut back expenditures during tough times, based upon perceived need more than real need. Solid customer relationships can ensure a bridge across times of economic uncertainty.

Be Different

How do you differentiate yourself from the rest? Market, advertise and serve your customer more and better than ever before. Studies of recessionary periods back through the 1960s show that companies that invest in advertising and marketing during uncertain economic periods show increased market share and vitality after the economy improves. Of those who do cut back their initiatives to communicate product value to customers, only a fraction survive long-term.

Listen to Your Customer

Who is the judge of quality? I mean, who knows if I am turning out a quality product or not? My years of experience must mean that I know something, so I should know about the quality of my own work — right? If I don’t, then what is the value of all these years? Well, the only judge of quality is in the eye of the customer. Regardless of what we think, perceive or know, the customer’s judgment with their purchasing dollar is the decision that will seal our fate. Listen to your customer. Listen like your very life depended upon it. Don’t listen to confirm that you are right; listen to find out where you are wrong, and then have the courage to change it. Unless you are spending only your own money to keep your company afloat, your opinion is the last one you want to hear.

The same goes for value-added and product differentiation. Listen to your customer to find out what is important and what makes you different. You will most likely be surprised at what you learn. Keep asking the same questions over and over of different customers. You will find that these things change over time with the ebb and flow of your customer base, as well as when their needs evolve and change. Your experience may stem from many years in the past, but you need to know what specific needs are as of now. Forget all that you know and attack the problem to learn everything anew. Expect things to be different, but allow yourself to be surprised if some turn out to be the same.

Change is Necessary

Making leaps in generating results seldom happens from “doing more of the same.” Great strides in performance usually result from doing things differently rather than doing more of a familiar process. Reinventing how you do things is hard when you have achieved moderate success with your current structure. Most people don’t like change. Even fewer want to change processes that have led to a current level of success. Our human nature tells us that is better to continue the moderate success with which we are familiar than to take a risk with a new procedure to possibly achieve a larger success we have never seen.

Generating increased sales in tough times takes courage. It requires you to question things that have worked in the past. Some of those things that need to be questioned are so ingrained that most of the time we don’t even see them. It is a good exercise to have a friend, who is not associated with your business, sit down with you. You should explain to them just how your business works. As you explain the various facets of your job, allow them ask you why — over and over and over. Eventually, you will begin to see through some of the assumptions you have made and taken as facts. Then you will be empowered to look at the type of changes that can get you beyond doing the same old thing just a little bit better.

Far too often new competitors enter our business categories and revolutionize how we do business. The reason they can do so, is because they aren’t smart enough to know it can’t be done that way. We too, must practice being ignorant of our industry. It may be the only way we can adequately reward ourselves for all the years we have spent doing our job. Being able to suspend our self-imposed limitations and still use our specific knowledge is not at all easy. But it could be the genius that leads us to take everything to the next level. The first thing to understand is that the best time to grow is when others are not.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Plaxo Pulse
  • Twitter
  • Share/Save/Bookmark